How to Make a Buttery Nipple Shot – Easy 2-Ingredient Recipe

Looking for a fun, creamy, and crowd-pleasing shot that’s as smooth as it sounds? The Buttery Nipple is a classic layered shooter made with just two ingredients: rich butterscotch schnapps and velvety Baileys Irish Cream. Whether you’re hosting a party, planning a girls’ night, or just want to try something new, this sweet and buttery shot is quick to make and seriously delicious. In this recipe, I’ll show you exactly how to layer it like a pro, plus tips to make it extra impressive.

Introduction

for the Buttery Nipple Shot Recipe

Looking for a sweet, creamy shot that’s guaranteed to be a crowd favorite? The Buttery Nipple might just be your new go-to. This fun and flavorful shooter blends the rich taste of butterscotch schnapps with the smooth, velvety touch of Baileys Irish Cream to create a layered drink that looks just as good as it tastes.

What makes the Buttery Nipple so special? It’s incredibly easy to make, uses just two ingredients, and always gets people talking—thanks to its cheeky name and irresistible flavor. Whether you’re hosting a party, celebrating a night in with friends, or just feeling like treating yourself to a mini dessert in a shot glass, this little beauty delivers every time.

1.🧾 Ingredients Overview

You only need two simple ingredients to make a classic Buttery Nipple shot, plus an optional garnish if you want to get fancy. Here’s what you’ll need:

✅ Butterscotch Schnapps – 1 oz

This sweet, buttery liqueur is the base of the shot. It brings that signature candy-like flavor that makes this drink irresistible.

Tip: Brands like DeKuyper Buttershots or 99 Butterscotch work great for this recipe.

✅ Baileys Irish Cream – 1 oz

This creamy liqueur adds smoothness and richness, balancing the sweetness of the schnapps.

You can also use other Irish cream brands like Carolans or Emmets if preferred.

🥄 Optional Garnish: Whipped Cream

Want to make it extra fun? Top your shot with a little whipped cream for flair and added sweetness. It’s not traditional—but it’s delicious.

2.📝 Step-by-Step Instructions

How to Make a Buttery Nipple Shot – Step-by-Step Recipe Guide

Ready to make your own Buttery Nipple? Follow these simple steps to get that perfect layered shot, just like a pro:

1. Prepare the Glassware

Start by selecting a shot glass (preferably a 2 oz glass). A wider, shorter glass works best for the layered effect.

2. Pour the Butterscotch Schnapps

Pour 1 oz of butterscotch schnapps into the bottom of the shot glass.
Tip: To avoid disturbing the layers, pour the schnapps slowly and steadily.

3. Layer the Baileys Irish Cream

Using the back of a spoon, slowly pour 1 oz of Baileys Irish Cream over the spoon and into the glass.
The spoon will help the cream gently float on top of the schnapps, creating the beautiful layered effect.

4. Optional Garnish

For a fun touch, add a dollop of whipped cream on top, or even drizzle a little caramel sauce for extra sweetness.

3.🥂 Optional Variations:

Shaken Version: If you prefer a blended texture, shake the schnapps and Baileys with ice before straining into a glass. It won’t have the layered look but will be just as delicious!
On the Rocks: Serve the drink over ice for a chilled, smoother version.

💡 Pro Tips and Fun Variations for the Buttery Nipple Shot

Ready to get creative with your Buttery Nipple shot? Here are some fun ideas and tips to make it your own:

🍬 Make It Stronger or Sweeter

Stronger: Add vodka or whiskey for a little extra kick. A splash of vanilla vodka pairs nicely with the butterscotch flavor.
Sweeter: If you want a sweeter drink, drizzle a little caramel syrup on top or stir in more butterscotch schnapps.

🍹 Fun Twists on the Classic

Flavored Schnapps: Experiment with different schnapps flavors like peach or apple for a unique twist. Peach schnapps creates a fruity, sweet contrast!
Chocolate Touch: Add a splash of chocolate liqueur or chocolate syrup for a dessert-like variation. It complements the creamy Baileys and butterscotch perfectly.
Layered Variations: You can also layer the Baileys with other creamy liqueurs, like Amaretto or Kahlúa, to give it a richer depth.

🌱 Vegan or Non-Dairy Options

Vegan Baileys: Replace the regular Baileys with a vegan-friendly Baileys Irish Cream (available at most grocery stores).
Non-Dairy Creamers: Use a non-dairy cream substitute like almond milk, coconut cream, or oat milk for a creamy yet dairy-free version.
Vegan Schnapps: Most butterscotch schnapps are vegan-friendly, but always check the ingredients to be sure.

4.❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make a larger batch? Yes! Multiply the ingredients by the number of shots you want to serve.
Can I make this drink in advance? While it’s best served fresh for the layered look, you can prepare the schnapps and Baileys in separate bottles and pour when you’re ready.
What glass should I use? A standard shot glass is perfect, but you can also get creative with mini cocktail glasses.

5.🎉 Serving Suggestions & Final Thoughts

The Buttery Nipple isn’t just a shot—it’s a conversation starter and a crowd-pleaser that’s perfect for any occasion. Here’s when to serve it and how to make the most of this creamy, sweet shot:

🥳 When to Serve It

Parties & Celebrations: The Buttery Nipple is a great addition to your party drinks menu—especially for birthdays, New Year’s Eve, or any time you’re celebrating with friends.
Girls’ Night or Casual Gatherings: This shot is perfect for a relaxed night with friends. Its smooth, dessert-like flavor makes it ideal for unwinding.
Holidays: Serve it at Christmas, Thanksgiving, or Valentine’s Day as a festive treat, or even as a unique addition to your Thanksgiving dinner shots!

🍰 Pairing Ideas

Desserts: Pair your Buttery Nipple shot with a slice of cheesecake, chocolate cake, or caramel flan for a decadent dessert combo.
Other Shots: The Buttery Nipple pairs beautifully with other sweet shots like the Pineapple Upside Down Cake or the Cake Batter Shot. Serve a variety of flavored shots for a fun party vibe!

🥂 Final Thoughts:

The Buttery Nipple is as easy as it is delicious. Whether you’re serving it at a party or enjoying it with friends, this layered shot will quickly become a favorite. So, grab your schnapps, your Baileys, and get ready to impress your guests with this sweet, creamy delight.

Call to Action:
Tried the Buttery Nipple shot? Don’t forget to share your photos and tag me on Instagram @fastprepkitchen And if you loved this recipe, be sure to check out more fun shots and cocktails here on FastPrepKitchen.com.

1. Stainless Steel Bar Spoon with Twisted Handle

Crafting the perfect layered shot is all about the pour—and this sleek, spiral-handled bar spoon helps you do it like a pro. Its long stem and curved bowl allow you to layer Baileys gently over schnapps without mixing the two.
✅ Perfect for cocktails, shots, and even stirring iced coffee.
👉https://amzn.to/4cvuiVd

2. 2-Ounce Crystal Clear Shot Glasses (Set of 6)

Whether you’re serving one or six, these beautifully crafted shot glasses make your drinks look professional and photo-ready. The clear glass highlights the layered effect, making your Buttery Nipple shots an instant party hit.
✅ Durable, dishwasher-safe, and great for hosting!
👉https://amzn.to/4lj4D67

3. Mini Measuring Jigger (1 oz/2 oz)

Accuracy matters, even in shots! A small jigger ensures your ratios are spot-on, every time. Go from beginner to confident mixologist with this simple, stylish tool.
✅ Double-sided, easy to grip, and bartending-approved.
👉https://amzn.to/4jjRQOW